In a 25-request shopping study, Instinct led on writing and Dots on product fit

Braintrust · 12 October 2026 · 25 requests
Better writing and better product fit were not the same winner
Written response quality · mean rank
Muse 2.24
Instinct 1.44
Dots 2.04
Product fit · mean rank
Muse 1.52
Instinct 1.40
Dots 1.28
Lower mean rank is better. A shorter bar wins.
What
- Braintrust's 25-request test: Instinct wrote best, Dots picked best by a small margin (1.28 vs 1.40).
- The best agent depends on the job: writing and shopping choices split.
- Our read: pick the agent by job, with Instinct for writing and Dots for choosing, and expect rankings to shift. One reviewer and 25 requests.